Midnight in Soap Lake
Matthew J. Sullivan
2025 · 416 pages · Mystery
How it reads
Midnight in Soap Lake is mystery (small-town mystery, specifically), and its dominant mood is eerie. It's atmospheric and uncanny, with a sense that something is wrong. The pace is moderate — neither a page-turner nor a slow burn — so it holds up whether you read it in long sittings or short ones.
It's set in a small town setting, in the present day, told in the third person, staying close to one character. Its central concerns are secrets, loss and grief and family. In weight it sits in the middle: substantial without being heavy going.
It stands alone, so there's nothing else you need to read first or after. The ending resolves happily. At 416 pages it's an ordinary novel's length. It's a hidden gem — known to relatively few readers.
Pick it up if…
- you're in the mood for something eerie
- you like finding books before everyone else
- you want a complete story in one book
Maybe not if…
- you need something cosy or heartwarming
All 15 dimensions
- Genre
- mystery
- Author gender
- male
- Author experience
- established
- Setting: place
- small town
- Setting: time
- contemporary
- Mood / feeling
- eerie
- Pace
- moderate
- Tone / weight
- balanced
- Length
- medium
- Narrative style
- third person, one viewpoint
- Publication era
- new release
- Popularity
- hidden gem
- Series vs standalone
- standalone
- Themes
- secrets, loss and grief, family
- Ending style
- resolved and happy
What these mean: the 15 dimensions of a book.
Books with a similar reading
The closest books in Match Book's catalogue across the same dimensions, and what they share.
- Rare BirdsL.B. HazelthornShares: mystery, eerie mood, balanced tone, small-town mystery
The Girl from Widow HillsMegan MirandaShares: mystery, eerie mood, balanced tone, moderate pace- BluejayMegan StocktonShares: mystery, balanced tone, small-town mystery, moderate pace
The Girl Who Stopped SwimmingJoshilyn JacksonShares: mystery, eerie mood, balanced tone, moderate pace
The Lake of Dead LanguagesCarol GoodmanShares: mystery, eerie mood, balanced tone, moderate pace
Watcher in the WoodsKelley ArmstrongShares: mystery, eerie mood, balanced tone, moderate pace
Appears in
Find a copy
Reviews on Goodreads ↗Match Book earns a commission on purchases made through these links, at no extra cost to you. As an Amazon Associate, Match Book earns from qualifying purchases.